Homeowner’s Guide: How To Redo Cabinets In Kitchen Spaces

The kitchen is the room that ages fastest. The layout you loved ten years ago now feels cramped. The finish that looked clean in the showroom has gone dull, chipped at every corner, and dinged around every handle. You want it fixed — but you're not sure whether that means a coat of paint, a box of RTA cabinets from the internet, or something else entirely.

Here's an honest breakdown of how to redo cabinets in kitchen, what each option actually delivers, and who it makes sense for.

Option 1: Resurface or Reface

Resurfacing keeps your existing cabinet boxes in place and replaces the visible parts — doors, drawer fronts, and sometimes the veneer on the face frames. It's faster than a full replacement and costs less upfront.

The pitch is appealing. The reality is more conditional.

Refacing works when the underlying cabinet boxes are structurally sound. If the boxes are warped, the shelves are sagging, or the interiors are water-damaged — and in Bethlehem kitchens, especially older homes in the South Side or historic districts, that's not uncommon — resurfacing puts a fresh face on a failing structure. You've spent money and the problems are still there, just hidden.

It also doesn't fix layout. If your kitchen doesn't flow the way you want it to, refacing won't change bad designs. You get the same configuration in a newer finish.

Worth considering if: your boxes are genuinely solid, your layout works, and you're primarily solving a cosmetic problem. Of all the scenarios about how to redo cabinets in kitchen, it's the most limited of the three options.

Option 2: RTA Cabinets

Ready-to-assemble cabinets are the middle-ground option that attracts a lot of attention for those used to shopping for everything on Amazon. And we get it — low price point, fast shipping, DIY-friendly marketing. The photos look good. The quotes look even better.

But their perceived value is their secret curse: they're built to a price, not a standard. Particleboard boxes, stapled drawer joints, slides that bind within a year. The savings that look real in the cart tend to evaporate during installation — when the cabinets don't fit the walls, the doors don't hang square, and the "easy assembly" turns into a weekend project that bleeds into a second one.

There's also the fit problem. RTA cabinets come in fixed sizes. Your kitchen doesn't. That gap between the last cabinet and the wall, the odd angle at the corner, the ceiling height that doesn't match any standard upper cabinet run — those get filled with filler strips and workarounds that a seasoned installer might manage, but that most homeowners won't.

If you're researching how to redo cabinets in kitchen on a tight budget, RTA is the option that looks most attractive on paper. Just go in clear-eyed about what you're getting and be prepared to deal with more than you bargained for.

Option 3: Custom Cabinets

Custom cabinets are built to your kitchen — not adapted to it. Every dimension is drawn to the actual room, every configuration designed around how you cook, store, and move through the space.

This is where the question of how to redo cabinets in kitchen shifts from cosmetic fix to long-term investment. Custom means a pull-out organizer that fits your specific cookware. It means upper cabinets that reach the ceiling instead of stopping eight inches short. It means a corner solution that actually works, not a lazy susan that spins half your spices into the back of the cabinet never to return.

The material difference is real too. Custom cabinets are built from solid wood and plywood — not particleboard — with dovetail drawer boxes, soft-close hardware, and finishes applied in a shop under controlled conditions. Built once, last for decades.

The tradeoff is time and cost. Custom cabinets take longer to produce than anything you can order online and cost more upfront than RTA. But for most homeowners, the math works — because you're not replacing them again in seven years.

Who Installs Custom Cabinets?

This is a question worth asking early, not after you've already ordered. Who installs custom cabinets matters as much as who builds them — because even well-made cabinets can be installed poorly, and installation errors are expensive to fix.

The cleanest answer: the shop that builds them should install them, or work with an installer they trust and use regularly. At Stofanak, every project is handled end to end — design, fabrication, and installation — by the same team. There's no handoff to a third-party crew who's never seen the cabinets before.

That matters especially in Bethlehem, PA, where older homes regularly present walls that aren't plumb, floors that aren't level, and layouts that need field adjustments. A shop that builds and installs knows how to handle those conditions. A separate installer working from someone else's cabinets is just solving problems as they come.

Making the Call

In our 75 years of experience, when clients ask how to redo cabinets in kitchen, the real answer comes down to what the client’s aspirations are, and what behind the scenes needs to happen to make their vision come to life. 

Resurfacing is a quick cosmetic fix for a quick cosmetic problem - usually with short-lived effects. RTA is a budget solution with real limitations that we know makes a whole lot of sense on paper, until you realize it doesn’t work in practice.

Custom cabinetry is a long-term investment in a room you use every day — and in the Lehigh Valley, it's one that holds its value. We love it when realtors call out a “Stofanak Kitchen” as a selling point in stunning local homes.

Stofanak Custom Cabinetry has been building kitchens in Bethlehem, PA since 1951. Three generations, every cabinet shop-built, every project designed to fit the actual room. If you're ready to stop tolerating your kitchen and start using it the way it was meant to be used, reach out or stop by.

‍