Why Ready To Assemble Cabinets (RTA) Are A Bad Idea

We get it. This is a fast-paced world and between making the lunches, getting to practices, doing the laundry, cleaning the house, and... well... everything else... you're likely strapped for time.

For many homeowners in Pennsylvania, the weekend is reserved for honey-do lists and projects that reflect the pride of ownership. But in our experience, unless you're a 3rd generation craftsperson, these projects rarely come out the way they're planned.

When it comes to RTA cabinets, the bait is enticing. Low cost, easy selection, and time savings (they're shipped to you without any time spent on showroom visits, on-site measurements, etc).

In this article, we'll review the surface-level appeal of RTA cabinets, but we'll also go over why they are—let's be honest—not such a great choice for anyone who truly takes pride in homeownership.

After 75 years of building custom cabinets, we've seen countless homeowners regret the RTA decision. The "savings" evaporate quickly. The "convenience" becomes frustration. 

Let's talk about why.

The Seductive Pitch (And Why It's Misleading)

Companies that make ready-to-assemble cabinets make compelling promises: significant cost savings (50-70% less than custom), quick delivery (ships in days, not weeks), easy DIY assembly (just follow instructions!), and wide selection of styles and finishes.

It’s like Amazon Prime for your kitchen, right?

The reality? Cost savings disappear when you factor in mistakes, replacement parts, tools you don't own, parts that are missing, instructions that you literally have to read 697 times (and cross-check with your partner to make sure you’re not going crazy), and eventual replacement with actual cabinets. 

Quick delivery means quick manufacturing with cheap materials and minimal quality control. "Easy" assembly assumes perfect conditions and woodworking experience most homeowners don't have.

The pitch sounds great until you're three hours into assembly with crooked doors, stripped screws, and a very angry spouse.

Why RTA Cabinets Actually Fail

The Materials Are Garbage

Most RTA cabinets use particleboard or MDF for cabinet boxes instead of plywood. Particleboard disintegrates when it gets wet—one sink leak destroys the entire cabinet. MDF is heavy, sags over time, and doesn't hold screws well when you need to adjust hinges after they start sagging (which happens fast).

Surface finishes are thin veneer or printed foil that peels at edges and corners. You can't refinish or repair them when damaged. Scratches reveal the cheap substrate underneath. Heat from appliances causes veneer bubbling and separation within a year or two.

The hardware fails even faster. Hinges are the cheapest available and won't last five years of daily use. Drawer slides are basic undermount or side-mount options—not soft-close, not full-extension, just cheap. Cam locks loosen over time and doors start sagging within months. Handle mounting screws strip out of particleboard after a few tightenings.

Compare that to custom cabinetry: plywood construction that won't disintegrate from moisture, solid wood face frames and doors, quality hinges like Blum that last decades, dovetail drawer construction instead of stapled joints. The difference isn't subtle.

Assembly Is A Nightmare

"Just follow the instructions" assumes you have woodworking experience and the right tools. Pre-drilled holes don't always align because manufacturing tolerances are loose. Cam locks and dowels strip easily if you're not experienced with them. One mistake during assembly weakens the entire structure permanently.

Assembly takes two to four hours per cabinet for someone experienced, much longer for beginners. You need a dead-flat surface to assemble properly—most garage floors aren't level. Temperature and humidity affect materials during assembly. Particleboard swells, veneer peels, panels warp.

Oh. And unless you’re an octopus, you’re going to need a friend that you can count on who is willing to sacrifice multiple weekends to help (can you hold a 50lb section in one hand, a level, your tools, and mounting hardware in the other?).

If that’s not enough, RTA kitchen cabinets often arrive with damaged panels or missing hardware because of how they're packed (and often returned). Missing pieces means waiting for replacements while your kitchen sits half-done. We've heard this story dozens of times: homeowner spends entire weekend assembling ten cabinets, gets them installed, realizes doors don't align, tries adjusting hinges for hours, finally gives up and calls us to replace them. Pays twice: once for RTA cabinets that failed, once for custom cabinets that actually work.

Installation Reveals More Problems

Assembly is one thing. Installation is another entirely.

RTA cabinets arrive in pieces, but installation requires them to be level, plumb, and square. Walls in Pennsylvania homes (especially older ones) are rarely straight or level. Cheap cabinets can't be shimmed and adjusted properly because they twist and rack under pressure. Countertop installers often refuse to template over RTA cabinets because they're not stable enough to support granite or quartz.

You either install them yourself (good luck getting them level) or pay an installer who'll charge the same rate as custom installation. So much for the cost savings.

Long-term? Doors start sagging within months from cheap hinges and particleboard compression. Drawers stick or fall off tracks. Joints loosen as cam locks back out and dowels work loose. Cabinet boxes bow under the weight of dishes and cookware. When something breaks, refinishing isn't possible. You're replacing entire cabinets, not repairing them.

The Hidden Costs Pile Up Fast

The "savings" evaporate the moment you start actually installing RTA cabinets.

Upfront hidden costs: Tools you don't own (drill, level, clamps, square - easily $200 or more). Replacement hardware when cheap parts fail during assembly. Extra panels when you make mistakes during assembly (everyone does). Installation labor if you give up on DIY halfway through.

Long-term costs: Replacement within five to seven years instead of twenty-plus with custom cabinets. Can't repair anything. Now face replacing entire units. Decreased home value because buyers see cheap cabinets and adjust their offers accordingly. Countertop replacement if cabinets fail while your granite is still perfectly good.

Time costs: Your weekend (or several weekends) spent assembling instead of with family. Frustration when things don't fit right. Living in a construction zone longer than necessary because assembly takes forever.

We've replaced enough failed RTA cabinets to see the pattern. Homeowners thought they were saving money and ultimately lost money, on top of time - straining everyone’s patience in the process.

What Actually Makes Sense Instead

If budget is genuinely tight, there are better options than RTA cabinets.

Semi-custom cabinets from reputable manufacturers offer better quality than RTA at lower cost than full custom. Stock cabinets from quality suppliers, professionally installed, will outlast any RTA option. Phased custom cabinet installation (do the kitchen now, bathrooms later) spreads cost while maintaining quality throughout.

What doesn't make sense: paying twice because you went cheap the first time. Wasting weekends on assembly frustration. Living with crooked doors and sticky drawers for years. Reducing your home's value with visibly cheap materials.

Assembled kitchen cabinets from a custom shop cost more upfront but last three to four times longer and actually add home value instead of subtracting from it. In fact, we’ll check ourselves on that one.

We’ve got some of our first customers whose cabinets made by our founder are still going strong!

The Bottom Line

After 75 years building custom cabinets in Pennsylvania, we've replaced enough failed RTA cabinets to know they're anything BUT the budget option.

The homeowners who call us after RTA disasters are in a corner and have asked, "How fast can you get the job done before I get divorced?"

The savings struggle is real. 

You work hard for your home but your kitchen deserves better than particleboard boxes you assemble yourself and replace in five months. 

Send us an email to get started. Or, if you’re located in Bethlehem, Allentown, Emmaus, or the Lehigh Valley, you owe it to yourself to stop the clicking and visit our showroom at 176 Nazareth Pike. 

Take the time. See what actual quality looks and feels like. Touch real wood construction instead of particleboard. Open drawers with real dovetail joinery instead of stapled corners. Feel the difference between Blum hinges and whatever cheap hardware came in that flat-pack box.

Pride of ownership starts with quality that lasts.

‍